Dee Jay Mathis — James Caan’s First Wife: Life, Age, Career, and Where She Is Now

Dee Jay Mathis is a name that holds quiet yet lasting significance in Hollywood history. She is best known as the first wife of the legendary American actor James Caan, who became famous for his role in The Godfather and many other classic films. Born in the early 1940s, Dee Jay Mathis was a talented dancer and actress who once shared her life with one of cinema’s most beloved stars. Her life story is not filled with the glitter and fame that surrounded her ex-husband, but it remains an intriguing tale of ambition, love, and mystery. Despite being married to a celebrity, Dee Jay chose a path of privacy and simplicity, staying away from the public eye for decades. Her journey from a young dancer in the late 1950s to a Hollywood wife, and later a private citizen, makes her story both inspiring and deeply human. This article provides a detailed look into Dee Jay Mathis’s life, career, family, and where she is today.

   Profile Summary: Dee Jay Mathis

Early Life and Background

Dee Jay Mathis was born in 1941 in Union, New Jersey, United States of America. Her birth name was Dorothy Jeanne Mathis, but she later adopted the stage name Dee Jay Mathis, which became her professional and public identity. She is an American citizen and belongs to the Caucasian ethnic group. Very little is known about her parents and early upbringing because she preferred to live a quiet and private life even during her years of fame. Some reports suggest she may have been an only child, while others mention that she might have had one sister, though her name remains unknown. Growing up in New Jersey, Dee Jay showed an early interest in performing arts, music, and dance, which later shaped her career path. She attended local schools and, after finishing her basic education, decided to follow her dream of becoming a performer. In the 1950s, when she was still in her teenage years, she moved to Los Angeles, California, to pursue a career in entertainment, joining the wave of dreamers who hoped to find success in Hollywood.

Career Beginnings — From Dancer to Actress

Dee Jay Mathis began her career as a dancer, and her talent quickly earned her opportunities in both television and stage performances. One of her earliest known appearances was on The Mitch Miller Show in 1959, where she performed as a dancer. This show was quite popular at the time, and it helped her gain recognition in the entertainment community. The same year, she joined the dancing ensemble of a Broadway musical titled “First Impressions,” which was based on Jane Austen’s classic novel Pride and Prejudice. Dee Jay worked not only as a dancer but also served as an understudy for the character Kitty Bennett, proving her versatility and professionalism. Her graceful movements and dedication helped her earn a respectable name among fellow performers.

In the mid-1960s, Dee Jay transitioned briefly into acting, appearing in small or uncredited roles in films. She appeared in the 1964 movie The Passy and later in the 1966 film Frankie and Johnny, where she worked as a dancer under Earl Barton’s choreography. Although her roles were minor, they reflected her deep love for performing arts. However, her acting career was short-lived, and after her marriage ended, she slowly disappeared from the entertainment industry. Despite her limited screen time, her charm and elegance made her memorable to those who followed early Hollywood stage performers.

Love Story with James Caan — How They Met and Married

Dee Jay Mathis’s life changed forever when she met James Caan in the late 1950s. At that time, both were young, ambitious, and struggling to make a name for themselves in Hollywood. They met in Los Angeles, possibly through mutual friends or industry events, and soon developed a close friendship that turned into love. Their chemistry was undeniable, and they began dating around 1959.

After dating for about two years, the couple decided to take their relationship to the next level and got married in 1961 in a private ceremony attended by close friends and family members. Their union symbolized the hope and glamour of young Hollywood — two dreamers building a future together. During their marriage, James Caan’s acting career was just beginning to take off, and Dee Jay was often seen accompanying him at early Hollywood events. She was supportive, loving, and elegant, often standing beside him during red carpet appearances and award nights. In 1964, they welcomed their only child, a daughter named Tara A. Caan, who became the center of their world. For a few years, they lived what seemed like a picture-perfect Hollywood love story.

Divorce and Life After James Caan

Despite the early happiness, Dee Jay Mathis and James Caan’s marriage began to face difficulties as Caan’s career grew rapidly. His busy schedule, frequent travel, and growing fame reportedly created emotional distance between the two. Some rumors also suggested issues of infidelity, though neither Dee Jay nor James ever publicly commented on such matters. Their marriage officially ended in 1966, just five years after their wedding. The divorce came as a surprise to many who had admired their relationship.

After the separation, Dee Jay Mathis decided to step away from Hollywood completely. While James Caan went on to become one of the most respected actors in the film industry, known for movies like The Godfather, Misery, Elf, and Rollerball, Dee Jay chose a life of privacy. She focused on raising her daughter, Tara, and avoided public appearances. Unlike her ex-husband, who married three more times, Dee Jay never returned to the entertainment spotlight or remarried publicly. Her choice to lead a quiet life away from fame has often been described as graceful and dignified.

Family and Children

Dee Jay Mathis and James Caan had one child together, a daughter named Tara A. Caan, who was born on November 5, 1964. Tara largely inherited her mother’s preference for privacy and has stayed out of the entertainment business. There is very limited public information about her life, though she is believed to have lived a stable and comfortable life thanks to her parents’ early success.

James Caan, on the other hand, went on to have four more children from his later marriages — Scott Caan, who is now a successful actor best known for his role in Hawaii Five-0, and sons Jacob Nicholas Caan, Alexander James Caan, and James Arthur Caan. While Tara remains the only child from Dee Jay’s marriage, the Caan family as a whole became widely known in Hollywood circles.

Dee Jay, however, remained devoted to maintaining her and her daughter’s privacy. She was occasionally mentioned in interviews or reports about James Caan’s life, but she herself avoided media attention and public appearances completely.

Where Is Dee Jay Mathis Now?

After her divorce from James Caan in 1966, Dee Jay Mathis withdrew entirely from public life. She never sought fame again, nor did she return to television or film. It is believed that she continued to live in the United States, possibly in New Jersey or California, and led a peaceful life away from the spotlight. Her absence from social media and public events makes it difficult to track her current activities, but reliable sources estimate that she is around 84 years old as of 2025.

Some unverified reports suggest she may have remarried later in life, but there is no public record to confirm that. What is certain is that Dee Jay Mathis valued her privacy and preferred a simple, quiet existence over Hollywood fame. Her decision to stay off the radar for nearly six decades has only made people more curious about her today.

During her younger years, Dee Jay Mathis was admired for her elegant style and graceful appearance. She often wore stylish short haircuts and glamorous dresses during her red carpet days with James Caan. She had a charming personality, full of warmth, professionalism, and poise — qualities that made her stand out even without being a mainstream star.

Dee Jay Mathis vs. James Caan — Life in Contrast

The lives of Dee Jay Mathis and James Caan took dramatically different paths after their divorce. James Caan’s fame skyrocketed in the 1970s with his role as Sonny Corleone in The Godfather, earning him international recognition and multiple award nominations. He continued to act in blockbuster films for decades and became a Hollywood legend.

Dee Jay, on the other hand, deliberately stayed away from fame and entertainment. She focused on her personal life, motherhood, and privacy. While James married three more times — Sheila Marie Ryan, Ingrid Hajek, and Linda Stokes — Dee Jay never sought the limelight again. Their contrast represents two different sides of Hollywood life: one of stardom and public recognition, and the other of quiet dignity and peace.

Lesser-Known Facts About Dee Jay Mathis

1. Her real name is Dorothy Jeanne Mathis.

2. She started her career as a professional dancer before acting.

3. She was part of the original dance ensemble of “First Impressions” in 1959.

4. She appeared in two films — The Passy (1964) and Frankie and Johnny (1966).

5. She was James Caan’s first wife, and they were married for five years.

6. She attended red carpet events like the Golden Globes with her husband.

7. After the divorce, she completely disappeared from Hollywood.

8. She is believed to be living privately in the USA as of today.

9. Her daughter, Tara A. Caan, lives a private life like her mother.

10. She remains one of the most mysterious figures from early Hollywood circles.

Legacy and Public Perception

Even though Dee Jay Mathis did not achieve mainstream fame, her story remains significant in Hollywood’s history. As the first wife of James Caan, she witnessed the rise of one of the greatest actors of his generation. However, her own life story represents the quieter side of the entertainment world — where not everyone seeks fame, and some prefer peace over publicity. Her elegance, independence, and decision to live privately make her an inspiring figure for those who value simplicity in a world often obsessed with fame. Today, her name continues to resurface whenever people discuss James Caan’s early life, reminding the world of the woman who stood beside him before he became a legend.

Conclusion

Dee Jay Mathis’s life may not have been filled with fame and red carpets, but it is a story of grace, strength, and choice. From her beginnings as a dancer in the 1950s to her short Hollywood career, her marriage to James Caan, and her quiet life afterward, every chapter of her journey reflects dignity and independence. She remains a symbol of the many individuals who once brushed shoulders with fame but chose a different path — one of peace and privacy. Though she lives away from the spotlight, Dee Jay Mathis continues to capture the curiosity of many, proving that sometimes, silence tells the most powerful stories.

FAQs About Dee Jay Mathis

Who is Dee Jay Mathis?
Former wife of actor James Caan and a retired dancer and actress.

When was Dee Jay Mathis born?
1941 in Union, New Jersey.

How long were Dee Jay Mathis and James Caan married?
Married in 1961 and divorced in 1966.

Do they have children together?
Yes, a daughter named Tara A. Caan (born 1964).

Where is Dee Jay Mathis now?
Living a quiet life in the United States, away from the public eye.

More from Viralfeed: Who Is Lisa Cadette Detwiler? All About Jim Cramer’s Smart And Stylish Wife